Skip to main content
Search US website

The 5 Hiring Mistakes You Need To Stop Making Now

5 Comments

December 20, 2011

Related Topics:

OPEN Forum Message

Test Your Business Skills

Take one or more of OPEN Forum's Crash Courses on topics like Leadership, Search Engine Marketing, Facebook and more.

Learn more

Hiring is an integral part of any business. Laying a solid human foundation will define the success (or failure) of your venture. That's why it's so important to get it right the first time. Of course, perfection is virtually impossible, but you can get close. But chances are, with your current system, you're not getting close enough.

Here are five of the most common hiring mistakes. The bad news is, you're probably making them. The good news is, you can definitely fix them.

Don't overdo it online

Using Web-based tools to reach prospective hires is essentially a must-do, but there is a saturation point. Remember that expanding your reach online will expand your application yield, so make sure that more actually is better for your business. Do you have the resources to manage that influx of applications? Are your existing online recruitment services sufficient for your needs?

Veteran About.com job search and career expert Alison Doyle says: "If you're a company who's getting more than enough applicants through your company website, then you may want to have a presence on social media—a Twitter page, a Facebook page, a Google+ page, a LinkedIn company page—but you may not need to do any more than that, given the applicant pool out there is so large."

Don't skimp on networking

There is no more trustworthy recruiting tool out there than your own judgment, or that of a friend. Avoid getting buried under a pile of applications by steering clear of job boards and other crapshoot general hiring resources. Instead, build in time to grow your network and reconnect with industry insiders who have the dish on who to hire.

David Shedd, blogger and author of B2B: Winning Leadership For Your Business-to-Business Company, says: "By most measures, 70 percent of all managerial jobs are filled by networking. If you are not out and about (at least one time a month) networking and meeting people in your geographic area and industry, then you are relying on others to find the right people. Networking broadens your perspective, enabling you to see the talent that is out there. You will also get to know more people who can refer you to other good talent."

Don't hire with your gut

It's a trap that ensnares managers everywhere, but it's risky and potentially costly for your company. Have a data-driven approach to hiring—prioritize past performance and tangible skills over charisma and a good personality match. It's a safeguard against choosing an underqualified candidate who will drain time, money, and productivity.

Geoff Smart, ghSMART CEO and author of Who: The Hiring Method, says: "Generally, don't hire with your gut feel. Most people hire with their gut—they just decide if they like someone or not and then they hire them. That's the most common way hiring happens in the world and it doesn't work, it leads to about a 50 percent hiring failure rate—that's based on about half a century worth of data on it."

Don't defer on top-level hires

The ideal situation is to have hiring professional who specialize in your company's different sectors. For example, if you have a tech systems division that needs a leader, an HR employee who is well-versed in that position's duties—not just what they are, but what they actually mean—significantly streamlines the vetting process. Getting more specific, sooner save times and money. Still, not all businesses, especially small ones, have the resources.

Mayank Chandra, head of executive search firm Antal International Network, writes in the Wall Street Journal: "The next best solution is to involve the department manager, who is, after all, best-suited to understand the job requirements and thus find the ideal person."

Image credit: bpsusf

What do you think?

Member avatar

Join the conversation ( 5 )

  • Laura Higgins 4 months ago

    Laura Higgins

    I absolutely agree with Gabriela. However, my emphasis has been very function-specific hiring in marketing. I laughed when I read this article because I'd just finished posting something similar -- http://http://www.laurahiggins.com/how-to-hire-a-great-marketer.html -- on how to hire a marketing person. My advice was 180 degrees from this author's regarding the "gut check" on hiring. Certainly, a competent interviewer will drill down relentlessly into the details of a candidate's experience and skill set and whether or not they are clearly qualified for the job. The rest IS going to be based on nonlinear, intuitive decision-making. Anyone who denies this is deluding themselves. We are human animals, and ultimately we make decisions based on highly complex, nuanced elements -- including hard and fast data,but not exclusively based on data!

    • Alison Murray 4 months ago

      Alison Murray

      Ha ha... I was wondering too!

  • Gabriela Ehrlich 5 months ago

    Gabriela Ehrlich

    I don't agree with the statement: "don't hire with your gut". In my experience the best combination is: hard facts (the experience, track record and good references) AND the gut feeling. I have hired based on hard facts only...not listening to my gut which told me NO....I paid for it dearly. Now I combine the two. If you have a bad feeling about a candidate deep down, even if all the facts speak for him/her, don't hire him/her.

    • Ed Wilson 4 months ago

      Ed Wilson

      Couldn't agree more! There needs to be a balance. There are too many that "talk the talk" and look great on paper, but when the rubber meets the road, there's too often a wheel missing. "Gut" kicks in, but that comes only from an ability to "read" people "between the lines".

Crash Courses

Earn 80+ IQ Points

The Art of Hiring

From where to find them to how to hire them, get the experts’ insights into how to attract and assess the best candidates for your company.

Launch course

Javascript is currently disabled. Please enable javascript for the optimal OPEN Forum experience.

All users of our online services subject to Privacy Statement and agree to be bound by Terms of Service. Please read.

© 2012 American Express Company. All rights reserved.