Skip to main content
Search US website

6 Things To Consider When Hiring An SEO Firm

5 Comments

April 12, 2011

Related Topics:

OPEN Forum Message

Watch MSNBC's Your Business

If you missed this week's show or want to catch up on past episodes, you can find the videos on OPEN Forum.

View videos

I don’t know about you, but I barely have enough time to run my small business let alone manage a successful search engine optimization (SEO) campaign. Over the past 18 months I have hired two companies, fired one and interviewed many (large and small). I am midway through the process of getting my company “optimized,” with a new partner. The experience has been enlightening, bumpy and rewarding all at the same time. Below, I have listed a few things to think about before signing on.

 

Step 1: Determine your goal

 

Take your time with this one, and make sure you are able to articulate your goal clearly. Who are you trying to reach? What do you want to say when you reach them? As a small business owner, I am very protective of my company’s brand and the niche it dominates. Of course the end game is to increase sales and profitability, but I don’t want to change the company’s persona to do it.

 

Step 2: Select a partner that “gets it”

 

Unlike many larger enterprises in our space, we are relationship driven—we don’t have scores of operators standing by to sell one-offs.  Our value is predicated on the expertise, resourcefulness and personal service we provide. I searched for a partner that was willing and able to understand my company’s unique qualities and then communicate them online while raising our visibility.

 

Step 3: The search

 

Two years ago, the idea of SEO was just trickling down to small businesses. I knew about SEO, but I really didn’t know anything about it. As luck would have it, while participating in a program at UCLA’s Anderson School, a professor suggested that I look into Hubspot—a do-it-yourself SEO provider. After several months of due diligence, and based upon a very enthusiastic recommendation from the professor, we took the plunge.

 

In my opinion the best part about Hubspot was that it:

 

  • Gives its subscribers an insider’s look at the process in one convenient location
  • Offers five hours of consultation, a forum to ask questions and have them answered and access to webinars, blogs and partners
  • Enables users to see what their competitors are doing and compare and contrast the quality and effectiveness of different websites in the same industry
  • Provides useful and specific information about visitors and visits
  • Gives ultimate responsibility for messaging to the subscriber (good for me since I am a control freak)

Step 4: Don’t be afraid to change

 

But don’t be a “flag in the breeze,” either. After several months with Hubspot, I decided to cancel my subscription because, among other reasons, the process was more expensive and time-intensive than we expected:

 

  • Also, the model seemed to be geared towards helping small businesses in local markets, and we are a small business in a global market.

Step 5: Now what?

 

Against my better judgment, I let go with one hand before grabbing on with the other. This said, I figured what we had in place was still working (fortunately we only moved our blog and not our website to Hubspot, so disconnecting wasn’t too painful). Almost immediately, I started a new search that entailed asking multiple resources for direction.

 

  • I leveraged my business connections, first. One was able to make a personal introduction with their SEO provider—an industry leader. I called, spoke with someone and got a list of great questions to ask and things to look for.
  • I reached out to our client base and received multiple leads—most of the companies were too large and had average monthly fees of $10,000-plus.
  • I asked for recommendations from my LinkedIn Marketing Group (be careful if and when you do this. I was inundated with responses, nine-tenths of which came not from end users but prospectors).
  • Based upon a more in-depth search, a process of elimination and a very detailed conversation with the sales team at my new provider, I made a decision.

Step 6: The takeaway


Unless you or someone in your office is highly skilled and has tons of time to devote to the process, I suggest you get professional SEO help. This is not to say you shouldn’t stay involved.  However, because the rules of the game are in a constant state of flux (check out this New York Times article “
Google Tweaks Algorithm to Push Down Low-Quality Sites”), it would take a team working every day all day just to keep up. Then there are the finer points of white hat, black hat, hidden site maps, link building, Meta tags, keywords etc. At some point you will need a real pro that is up to the task. In short, know what you don’t know, and then hire the best you can afford.

 

Stay tuned…

 

Want to hear more about how things are going today: the hiccups and successes? Stay tuned for the my next installment. To keep things interesting and relevant, our new partners (brave souls that they are), have agreed to join the discussion by responding to my comments and adding a few of their own.  

 

OPEN Cardmember Susan Roth took the helm of Trims Unlimited in 1985. Since then the company has regularly been recognized as one of the nation’s fastest growing private companies. 

What do you think?

Member avatar

Join the conversation ( 5 )

  • Kent Lewis 1 year 1 months and 17 days ago

    Kent Lewis

    A fine article that covers the basics. I do want to make the point that a truly strategic SEM vendor is more of a partner that helps move the business forward by thinking outside of the box, leveraging its network and generally looking at the company's overall success factors. I've expanded on my methodology in this article: http://www.dmnews.com/get-beyond-clicks-and-conversions/article/90202/

  • SUSAN ROTH 1 year 1 months and 17 days ago

    SUSAN ROTH

    Thank you! Our SEO partner will have a post on Open in the near future, and I will follow up with an update on first quarter results with our new firm. Amazingly, we have made it to the first page with several key industry phrases. I hope readers continue to find the story helpful and the process interesting.

  • community manager 1 year 1 months and 17 days ago

    community manager

    Susan - congratulations on your first post on OPEN Forum as a Cardmember contributor. The information you share is a good primer for small businesses exploring SEO.

  • SUSAN ROTH 1 year 1 months and 18 days ago

    SUSAN ROTH

    Lori,Thanks for your comment. Here's what I have learned to date: part of the process is actually going through the process. I needed my first experience to help drive my second towards a more successful outcome. While this may sound like gibberish, the bottom line is to be patient and learn as you go. It is impossible (or at least it was for me) to get everything right the first time out of the gate. Even if I had unlimited dollars to spend, I think learning by doing is part and parcel of obtaining a successful result.Susan

  • Lori Gama 1 year 1 months and 18 days ago

    Lori Gama

    Susan, I'm so proud of you and applaud your determination to do your SEO the right way: by hiring a professional Search Engine Optimization expert. May I offer a few more tips for people who are searching for that right person?Do ask your colleagues if they can recommend someone whom they've worked with and had great results. Even so: interview that person to make sure she or he is a right fit for you (just like Susan advised) and check their street cred: do some searching for an SEO expert in your area and state and see who shows up on page one in Google. If that person can't walk the talk, forget about that one and move on in your search. When you do find someone that you think is "THE ONE", interview her or him to find out if she's a White Hat (follows the rules) or practices "Black Hat" techniques (breaks the rules). Have her spend three minutes showing you how Google "thinks" when a user searches (she should be able to quickly educate you in layman terms); see what she says about Bing, Yahoo and Facebook searching and talk to her references and check their search results. Also, see what your prospective SEO expert says about social media marketing. If she or he does NOT integrate it into the SEO work, move on and find someone who DOES. It's really more Social Search Optimization instead of only Search Engine Optimization.Believe it or not, there ARE some SEO experts with reasonable fees for the small business owner. Take what you used to spend on newspaper and yellow pages ads and invest it in your SEO expert. You'll get great revenue growth if you've done your homework to find the right person.

Crash Courses

Earn 124+ IQ Points

Search Engine Marketing

Most business owners would probably agree – appearing in top search results is becoming more and more critical to attracting customers. Learn from OPEN Forum experts what you need to know about optimizing your website, driving more traffic through...

Launch course

Javascript is currently disabled. Please enable javascript for the optimal OPEN Forum experience.

All users of our online services subject to Privacy Statement and agree to be bound by Terms of Service. Please read.

© 2012 American Express Company. All rights reserved.