Is Social Media Failing to Produce Business Leads?

Is Social Media Failing to Produce Business Leads?

Jul 07, 2010 -

Former President of CBS News Andrew Heyward wrote in the Harvard Business Review last year that “every company is a media company,” summarizing the idea that marketing is shifting to an environment where advertisers need to produce compelling content in order to succeed.

 

Recent data suggests that this is indeed the case, and that looking at social media services like Twitter and Facebook strictly as lead generation tools might be counter-productive, especially for companies that focus on business-to-business sales.

 

LeadForce1, an online marketing automation service provider, studied website visitor data for 218 companies with a social media presence from February through April of this year. The results overwhelmingly showed that visitors who arrived at corporate websites via Twitter and Facebook engaged mostly with content – specifically a company’s blog – as opposed to exploring products or submitting a contact us form.

 

Diving into the numbers, when users arrive from Twitter, they are more than six times more likely to view a blog post than a Contact Us form. When they arrive via Facebook, the ratio isn’t quite as high, but nonetheless, blog posts and a company’s About page make up the bulk of user visits. About 63 percent of all of the visitors from both Twitter and Facebook look at only a single page.

 

The conclusion, then, from LeadForce1 is that “Facebook and Twitter do not bring in Leads – these can be used as channels to engage with your existing customers, media, other stakeholders, or for nurturing existing prospects, but not as a medium for generating leads.” With the vast majority of businesses still not measuring the ROI of their social media efforts, that might be seen as a discouraging data point.

 

However, I would argue that such a conclusion is short sighted, since it doesn’t measure the ongoing impact that engaging with customers and producing quality content can have on the long-term growth of your company. It doesn’t take into account a fundamental principle of social media marketing – the one that Heyward summarized so well in his statement about the evolution of advertising.

 

The stats are also a bit of a self-fulfilling prophecy – as marketers become more savvy and use social media for conversation and content as opposed to solely direct sales and lead generation, it would make sense that the majority of referral traffic from social media sites is going to content as opposed to product pages and submission forms.

 

Thus, the thing to keep in mind is that while linking your audience to a blog post might not translate directly to a sale, it might translate to a blog subscription, a retweet, or a share on Facebook. And that audience – which will grow with every quality piece of content you produce – can be re-engaged down the line with news about your products or special offers that directly drive sales.

 

While social media shouldn’t be thought of in the same fashion as more traditional forms of marketing where lead generation happens at the point of arrival, it would be a mistake to write it off as simply a communications tool with no direct correlation to new customer opportunities.

 

Image courtesy of iStockphoto, temniy  

Tags: cbs, andrew heyward, adam ostrow, twitter, mashable, facebook, leadforce1, roi, social media, marketing

23 11

Article Comments (11)

  • Jamie Lynn Morgan

    http://www.linkedin.com/in/jamielmorgan
    linked in badge

    Relationship Philosophy Destination…

    (Jul 07, 2010)
    Adam, I totally agree with you on this. Any business looking for that "quick" lead return with social media is going to be disappointed, but I also thing the companies that are aren't engaging and communicating either. It is the businesses that are having the conversations that will ultimately reap the rewards.

    Jamie Lynn Morgan
    http://getsocialsite.com
  • David Cherry

    http://www.linkedin.com/in/yourinternetnetworkingsolution
    linked in badge

    Owner of Your Internet Networking…

    (Jul 07, 2010)
    Totally agree Jamie!! Communication is key!
    I do realize that lead generation is important for any company. However I find social networking very important for brand awareness and customer service! Both of which can lead to new business if kept up!
  • Victor Cheng

    http://www.linkedin.com/in/victorcheng
    linked in badge

    CEO Coach & Strategic Advisor

    (Jul 07, 2010)
    I totally disagree with the idea that social media doesn't need to be held accountable for return on investment. I'm frankly sick and tired of all the buzz and hype around facebook and twitter as huge lead generators for business-to-business marketing purposes.

    Here's my advice to all the social media experts out there - take a finance class.

    Business are build on profit margins and cash flow generated by doing business with customers who you treat really well. End of story.

    If it doesn't produce cash flow, it should either not be in your marketing mix at all or it should be less than 20% of it. (Example: PR isn't very trackable, so doing some is okay, but not more than 20% - my 2 cents)

    A follower or a fan is NOT the same as bonafide customer who pays you cash. They are simply not the same thing.

    This is especially true as you go into higher end, more expensive b2b sales - $50k+ per transaction. As CEO coach, I work with people many people who are b2b buyers.

    At the C-level, unless you're in an Internet industry (and 99% of C-level executives are not), these people simply do not use twitter or facebook (though interestingly in my research they all DO use linkedin).

    How do I know this?

    I ask them. You know, old fashion, talk to your customers face-to-face market research (and of course looking at my own stats).

    Finally, this is not an indictment of all social media for b2b purposes. I've found blogging and linkedin to be useful lead generation sources (again by looking at my ROI and via customer interviews).

    I have been looking for real case studies of b2b ROI via facebook or twitter that's not focused on social media consulting/education, and for the life of me can not find one.

    The data CLEARLY shows ROI in this case is the exception, and most definitely not the rule.

    -Victor Cheng
    Business Coach
  • Ruth Portnoy

    http://www.linkedin.com/pub/ruth-portnoy/5/716/482
    linked in badge

    You need to know how to integrate your…

    (Jul 08, 2010)
    Well said, Adam. I am in the nonprofit sector, and all I hear is "show us results."
    But the truth, as you point out, is that it's an ENGAGEMENT tool. Another point of entry to involve potential volunteers and donors - and to create a little buzz about a project, event or cause. Sigh. We always want the "magic pill." There is none. Relationships take work and, ultimately, human contact.

    Ruth Sternberg Portnoy, development & communications advisor
  • Terrance Barkan, CAE

    http://www.linkedin.com/in/terrancebarkan
    linked in badge

    CEO at GLOBALSTRAT llc

    (Jul 08, 2010)
    Having conducted a study of how 800 organizations are deloying social media, the results described in the article are not surprizing. Social media is not well understood by senior company managers and therefore is often being deployed in ways that generate traffic but not results.

    One of the first mistakes is confusing followers or fans with customers. This includes not defining in advance who exactly the company is trying to reach. (For example, knowing who your best customers are and focusing on attracting more of that type of customer as opposed to a shotgun approach).

    Social media can be viewed as a new communication channel (it is a lot more than that as well). Communications basics calls for understanding your audience and target markets as a first priority together with defining what you are trying to achieve.

    I observe that a lot of "peer pressure" is driving social media adoption as every company CEO understands that he/she must "do something" in social media but is not really sure what that is.

    It all starts with a strategy... Anyone interested in a copy of the social media survey report (800 plus organizaqtions surveyed) or a social media strategy white paper can request a free copy from www.globalstrat.org